I do believe that it has remained the public’s opinion that women must “be
one of the men” in order to be a prominent leader; However, I do not feel that
this should be the view that the public holds. While it is surely reasonable to
ask that a woman does not burst into tears at the slightest mention of hardship,
I feel asking a woman to completely suppress her emotions restricts her benefit
to a cause. Women were given their personalities and emotions for a reason, and
human kind would cease to function if these traits did not exist. Men and women
were intentionally created to be different, and to balance each other with
these differences. Both have faults and values, which is why it is essential
that the two sexes work together and on equal terms. While the stereotypes of
men and women are both grossly exaggerated, these stereotypes do bring up some important
and relevant differences between the two genders that explain the necessity to
have both as leaders. Men tend to be more action-oriented and aggressive, and
women tend to be more emotionally-led and compassionate. While either side can
be argued as a positive or negative in certain situations, it is easy to see
how only getting one side for EVERY situation could lead to problems. Men are
often seen as better leaders because they generally have an easier time putting
aside their emotions and making level-headed decisions, but this is not always
the case. Men are also more rash and quicker to jump to violence. For occasions
when violence is not the best solution, a women’s softer disposition could be
the necessary ingredient. However, because our world is dominated by male
leadership and therefore male thought, emotion is often associated with
weakness or as “an act” to get sympathy. Yet in a cruel double standard, women
that show very little emotion are considered cold-hearted and mean. Political
women such as Hilary Clinton are under constant scrutiny to achieve an unrealistic
balance of being the “right amount of women”. People want them to look and act
in an attractive way, yet if they are doing this too much people believe they
are only getting by on their looks. People want them to show compassion and
womanly reason, yet if they are too soft on enemies or get emotional people
feel they can’t handle pressure. I feel a women’s personality is necessary in the
leadership world, and that women should stop being the subject of such close criticism
so that they can focus on what really matters.
Thoughtful and well reasoned response to the prompt. I agree with your assertion that, while men and women have distinguishably different characteristics, both the male and female perspective needs to be heard in leadership. We do a disservice to everyone by preferencing any sex/gender for positions of power. Good job.
ReplyDelete